IB ChemistryStructure 33.1S3.1.7
S3.1.7HL

Discontinuities in IE Trends

Period 3 anomalies explained by sub-shell structure and electron pairing.

🟣 This is Higher Level (HL) content.

📘 IB Understanding

First ionisation energy (IE₁) is the minimum energy required to remove one mole of electrons from one mole of gaseous atoms in their ground state:

M(g) → M⁺(g) + e⁻

The general trend across Period 3 is an increase in IE₁ due to increasing nuclear charge while electron shielding remains relatively constant. However, there are two distinct discontinuities that provide empirical proof for the existence of energy sublevels.

1st Ionisation Energy across Period 3

Period 3 First Ionisation Energy Bar Chart 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500 IE₁ (kJ mol⁻¹) 496 738 577 786 1012 1000 1251 Na Mg Al Si P S Cl Dip 1 Dip 2 Element (Period 3)

Anomaly 1: Mg → Al

Mg: [Ne] 3s². Electron removed from 3s subshell

Al: [Ne] 3s² 3p¹. Electron removed from 3p subshell

The 3p subshell is slightly higher in energy and further from the nucleus than the 3s subshell. The 3p electron is therefore easier to remove, despite Al having a higher nuclear charge.

Anomaly 2: P → S

P: [Ne] 3s² 3p³. Three unpaired electrons in 3p (↑ ↑ ↑)

S: [Ne] 3s² 3p⁴. One orbital now has a paired electron (↑↓ ↑ ↑)

The paired electron in S experiences spin-pair repulsion (inter-electronic repulsion) within the same orbital. This raises its energy and makes it easier to remove, so S has a lower IE₁ than P.

Electron Configuration Summary

Element Config IE₁ (kJ mol⁻¹) Explanation
Na3s¹496One 3s electron, easily removed
Mg3s²738Full 3s, higher Zeff
Al3s² 3p¹5773p electron higher energy → easier to remove
Si3s² 3p²786Increasing Zeff
P3s² 3p³1012Half-filled 3p, no pairing
S3s² 3p⁴1000Spin-pair repulsion in paired orbital
Cl3s² 3p⁵1251Increasing Zeff dominates
Ar3s² 3p⁶1521Full outer shell, highest Zeff

⚠️ Common IB Mistake

Do NOT explain the anomalies using "special stability" of half-filled or full subshells. The IB requires explanations based on orbital energy levels (3s vs 3p) and electron-electron repulsion (spin-pairing). This is a key distinction from some other syllabuses.

⚠️ Exam Tip

These anomalies mirror Period 2 (Be→B and N→O). You must be able to explain both periods using electron configurations and orbital diagrams. Examiners may ask you to compare the two periods directly.

← 3.1.6 IE Anomalies3.1.8 Transition Elements →